The appeals panel were provided with statements from each of the clubs involved in the protest, as well as appearance statistics relating to the fixtures, and matches prior/following the fixtures in question.
1. That the protest against Edinburgh City 2 by Dundee 1 be upheld.
2. That the protest against Edinburgh City 2 by Northern Storm be upheld.
As per point 3, the SKA are committed to working towards a system that is clear and has agreement from all parties before beginning of the 2015/16 season. In the short-term the current protest process will continue to operate if called upon by on team lodging a protest against another.